Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

The series finale is titled "White Orchids" and is written by Bruno Heller, Tom Szentgyorgi and Jordan Harper. https://twitter.com/jordan_harper/status/540347887855489024

And here I was praying for red. This sounds suspiciously like wedding bells. Blarg....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Does anyone else ever miss The Mentalist while they're watching it? (Just happened to me again with S7 E1.)

It sure is a strange feeling. How can you miss something when it's right there?

And yet, I do.


Come to think of it...I miss the bustle and zing of this WIRJ Board as well. 
And yet, here I am writing on it, so how can i miss it...?
Ever since the Red John episode in Season 6, I often feel discombobulated inside. I wonder if that feeling will soon be deemed as the RJ effect...a new disorder caused by intense disappointment at TV storyline debacles. We'll tell our insurance companies to send Heller the bill. ;-P

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #18509 • By mrsjane
Show this theory

please help out a fello mentalist (the old mentalist) fanatic...

http://link.email.dynect.net/link.php?H=WpfRqTFmqv45GbmvFQgMtLB7mdAR2keMec7qjqKstHEQL1%2Fa8UWwNMIreGfbMN08QkLv1YP%2BBI8Sr30a7QqCaOLqAs4QlgcKy%2B66XHjcdNKt0WzqPSXIrg%3D%3D&G=21&R=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.gofundme.com%2Fi7rs34&I=20141204000610.085D9A033B52%40mail6-03-ewr.dyndns.com&X=MHw3NzY2NjI6VEVNUElEXzQ5OzF8Nzc2NjYzOlFVRVVFSURfMTg3OTk3MzAwOw%3D%3D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I really hate to sound so negative but last season after the complete shock of the Red John reveal I still kept hope alive that we would get at least a RJ teaser or a Stiles/Haffner return In the finale, something mind blowing but instead they finally gave us the JISBON Casablanca rip off nobody wanted. ...................after that I was like "fuck this show". It is what it is ....a Sherlock Holmes ripoff crime procedural on network tv created by the guy who was booted off HBO ...........I don't want to watch this final season but I have to I've watched every episode more than once and Was such a fan of the show and Red John that I just can't believe that this show that I once considered entertaining and smart could go so horribly wrong I don't even know why I'm writing this my head feels like it's gonna explode when I think about the Red John reveal and the "New Beginning". Why is this show coming back for 13 episodes of this fuckin nonsense? The show should have ended with RJ's death, No? Ok, end it with Jisbon but just fuckin end it already .................Red John' deathly afraid of birds? Calls 9-1-1?? Blinks I'm sorry??? and where the fuck is Stiles? Please tell me he wasn't killed off camera...........fuckin crazy.............the whole execution of the entire season 6 was insane ............ They took an amazing actor like Pedro Pascal and did nothing with him.......... Red John is The Mentalist and without him this show is just awful recycled garbage ..........take a shit in a The Mentalist episode generator and this is what you get - fuckin nonsense -.........................................for me the first 3 seasons were great and Timothy Carter was Red John , cause seasons 4 & 5 were a giant RJ jerk off , and season 6 was just a fuckin train wreck ... A complete ball drop FUCK YOU FOR WAISTING MY TIME !!!!!! FUCK YOU!!!!! -------------------------------------------------

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Why?...............why even have a 13 ep seventh season? What's the point? This is a fuckin joke .......... It's crazy how far this show has fallen ..........season 6 was a train wreck. Are they really gonna do 12 murder of the week eps with a jisbon wedding finale............ I would like to see in the series finale somehow Lisbon finds something of Jane's that proves he is Red John something that only RJ could own ..............combine Fight Club with the Usual Suspects Kyser Soze reveal ..............that would be crazy.........one can still hope. .........let me get this straight Fisher is written out of the show in 2 lines of exposition and replaced by a GVP rip off (goody two shoes with daddy issues). How fuckin original of you Bruno Heller ........ They should of made Fisher the murder victim in the first episode but instead the victim is an undercover agent murdered by a bowling alley owner and Jane solves it by doing his guiding the perp's hands and reading her eyes trick. ...... This whole season better not be re-hashed garbage ........................................... By the way tell me Gotham isn't the biggest piece of shit ever................usual Heller M.O. The show will start off strong and then spiral out of control without any direction........teenage Catwoman witnesses the Wayne's murder? The Riddler is GCPD's forensics expert??Fish Mooney??? Hey let's throw in a young Bruce Wayne cutting himself, quick give Selina Kyle a glass of milk... Get it? She's gonna be Catwoman and she likes milk .... Fuckin wow....... Harvey Dent flipping a coin, Cobblepot eating a fish ..... This show is eating a dick .......this show is gonna implode faster than Rome (2 seasons- no real finale).

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What is there REALLY to talk about with "Nothing But Blue Skies?"  I'm tired of hearing myself express "Nothing But Disappointment."  I had to keep rewinding the show on my laptop because I'd get distracted by more interesting things -- and I actually forget about it airing.  

However, I will say….what show supposedly waiting for "years" to see two leads come together romantically…just SKIPS over the whole "we finally did it" stuff.  Don't get me wrong -- I'm SO happy!! Because I DON'T want to see Jibson half naked, making out or in a bed together, and the good thing is, I actually think we might never actually have to…!!  

But I need to point out that it's HIGHLY UNUSUAL to have some long awaited epic love affair finally happen at the bequest of all the love lorn fans…and then…show nothing?  Ha..ha…

Even just Lisbon's BRIEF moment of seeing PIKE at the end was SO MUCH BETTER, had so much more heat and chemistry --- than a whole unbearable hour of lame Jibson, with Jane -- trying to prove he loves her [without anyone knowing] by being protective and chivalrous "Don't speak to her THAT way!"  This is HARDLY an exciting secret office romance…it's more like a BROmance if anything…

ANd, I think if Jane really liked Lisbon in a sexual way, he would have put the swan in her pocket A LONG time ago [no pun intended lol]

Seriously, break these two up for the betterment of everyone, especially the SHOW!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hello guys!!! Only one question, why jane is still wearing his ring?? I feel there is something under the storyline, something you know about redjohn, jane e co. By the way, i miss the mentalist and this site!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on