Who is Red John

Theory #10337 • By utkarsh

Show this theory

ok guys, to add to my previous reasons from the post just below.

1- Minelli has been twice brought into the show after his resignation in season 2. now both of them were unnecessary you could say, or atleast the one in the santa episode.
2- dont you think heller would make sure the red john person is faded from the memory of people for some seasons so they get that ah moment. many would have even forgotten minelli.

3- in the 100 episode alexa shultz and bob kirkland are brought into the show in the end requesting red john things from minelli. just to divert attention maybe?
and kirkland is shown deliberately to be creepy imo. and then he is made to kill jason lennon under very suspicious circumstances.

4- ellis mars and todd johnson are brought into the picture soon thereafter to divert the attention.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

ok guys, first of all, kudos to heller for creatng such a marvel
and to baker for such a lively and impeccable portrayal of jane. now to
business here.

most importantly, Jane had a handshake with Minelli in the 100th episode and lorelei commented bout that in like 104th episode or something. dont you think..?

   so what do you think PJ is? a wannabee kid
detective who would wait for the clues in a treasure hunt to fetch the
biggest motive of his life? and what would yhe creator of the show
think? they make sure his plan is revealed only in teh end of even the
pettiest of his tricks and this is the magnum opus of his life.....and 4
people other than him know it.....wow......i dont buy it and it makes
for a boring chase as well i think.

      so jane is playing the big strategy in this masterful chess game to trap the king..


the biggest move he has made to date is the list of fake rj suspects,
not the one he gave to kirkland (or planted) but the one he showed to
lisbon......i think he requested lorelei to shoot that vide tape for him
when they were together and he put those 7 names there just to confuse
everyone around him..and he promptly destroyed the dvd which is
suspicious...so i think he is just confusing everyone else and even rj
if he is too active ion bugging his space..and eventually he would say
this is the man i knew from before was rj and just wanted to trap him as
he was so clever......and my vote is on Virgil Minneli..

1- minneli was out of vacations during the mexico killings.
2- he has been reintroduced in one flash back episode and once while fishing which i dint think there was any use really for.
3-
he is a solid character artists and the promoters wouldnt want RJ to be
some lightweight guy like maybe the guy playing smith..or the sherrif
4- he is well connected and has the age needed
5- bertram could be reporting it to him as he was the predecessor..

but anyhow, the list of 7 ought to be a fake..jane is planning the ruse behind that ploy

also this guy has given his views on why he thinks it could be minelli

http://webuiltthepyramids.tumblr.com/post/36512971896/evidence-for-and-against-minelli-being-red-joh....

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

ok guys, first of all, kudos to heller for creatng such a marvel and to baker for such a lively and impeccable portrayal of jane. now to business here.

   so what do you think PJ is? a wannabee kid detective who would wait for the clues in a treasure hunt to fetch the biggest motive of his life? and what would yhe creator of the show think? they make sure his plan is revealed only in teh end of even the pettiest of his tricks and this is the magnum opus of his life.....and 4 people other than him know it.....wow......i dont buy it and it makes for a boring chase as well i think.

      so jane is playing the big strategy in this masterful chess game to trap the king..

   the biggest move he has made to date is the list of fake rj suspects, not the one he gave to kirkland (or planted) but the one he showed to lisbon......i think he requested lorelei to shoot that vide tape for him when they were together and he put those 7 names there just to confuse everyone around him..and he promptly destroyed the dvd which is suspicious...so i think he is just confusing everyone else and even rj if he is too active ion bugging his space..and eventually he would say this is the man i knew from before was rj and just wanted to trap him as he was so clever......and my vote is on Virgil Minneli..

1- minneli was out of vacations during the mexico killings.
2- he has been reintroduced in one flash back episode and once while fishing which i dint think there was any use really for.
3- he is a solid character artists and the promoters wouldnt want RJ to be some lightweight guy like maybe the guy playing smith..or the sherrif
4- he is well connected and has the age needed
5- bertram could be reporting it to him as he was the predecessor..

but anyhow, the list of 7 ought to be a feke..jane is planning the ruse behind that ploy

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theory #9618 • By utkarsh

Show this theory

so guys for a moment let us think from jane's point of view..

he would know that he cudnt trust all the clues left by rj as they cud v well be planted there instead..now one very curious thing (most) is as to how could RJ have come up with the 7 names that Jane did....so i thought maybe.....he got lorelei into confidence and staged the shoot about the suspects and thanked her for that..as she had by then started to doubt rj himself..i dont recLL the episode exactly when he bumped his car and faked it and let lorelei escape.....m sure there would have been some place they could have shot that video..

because you know that list of 7 thing is somehow not adding up..feels boring and even lame......i dunno..its gone way too confusing already..

i remember in the 1st season maybe, the mexico killings coincided with the leaving of Minneli for few days on holiday.....so maybe jane knows it..or mashburn?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of utkarsh (39)