Who is Red John?

Theories of Stoopkid (372)

Its not mashburn. Rj has views and beliefs and mashburn is just a rich guy whos bored.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I wanna hear from people who think janes list is a trick and red john is not one of the 7. I think it makes for great convo and is more plausible that zombie partridge theorys. Even if partridge was alive he doesn't posses the smarts red john has . Hes just some kid who hates jane. Rj loves jane . So tell me what u guys think? I am almost positive i know its someone close or from the team. The gps trackers are key. Rj could of killed partridge weeks before when he magically came up with janes list but no he waited until the trackers were put on .

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10559 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

Has anyone noticed that something is definitely wrong with grace? She was just married and ever since this rj stuff happened she has been wearing a blank depressed look on her face...what could it be? I have posted many times accusing her as being rj but i havent even seem anyone question how she has been acting. Weird relationship she has with styles too. Any thoughts ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10544 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

The list is a ploy . Tiger tiger is a group to find rj. Thats why jane has them all in the same room bc he knows this will force rjs hand. Genius. I may be wrong about the lorelie tape being made by jane but i just want people to think outside the box. The list is so far from rj iys kinda silly. A misdirection for not only rj and janes team but also for us. Whenever i say van pelt is rj people get mad saying shes too young. She is not too young do the math. Rj may of been her father but i am sure she killed james family .

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10434 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

The Lorelie tape was faked. I also do not believe Rj killed her. Her neck was not slit as he always does...Tiger tiger was likely behind that murder. Tiger Tiger is an anti red john group. Jane is using them. Jane showed lisbon the tape. Lisbon then tells Van pelt and the rest about the list. If Rj knew about the list way crazily magically earlier like we are led to believe then the partridge would of been dead earlier. But thats not the case! The gps trackers are what set red john into action on the list becuase he/she had no idea prior...Jane knowing that Rj is hunting tiger tiger, what better way to lure the MAIN TIGER/TIGRESS than to hold a party for everyone on the list under the same roof. When lisbon asks jane "how could red john know what the list was " jane replies "idk it must be a trick" but its his own trick. God hes smart. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok now that everyone is caught up can we now start the real discussions about this fake list! Lol. But seriously nobody on the list is the red john. The list is a ploy to force red johns hand. Please no more partridge talk, jane looked him dead in the eye and if partridge knew what was going on we could tell. Styles knows who rj is. Could it be his son? Maybe his daughter ? The buggest question i have it how did rj find out about the gps trackers? I believe there is only about 3 people who knew about that. Also i believe the lorelie tape was made by jane . I know people are gonna doubt me cuz i think outside the box . Think about it: jane had two suspect list. One kirkland stole . The other he made lorelie recite on tape . He dis this to see how certain people acted. Jane knows everyone in that house is not rj . But he knows rj wants them all dead . Chess . Make a move so that your opponent thinks they have you and just when they think that check mate. Red john is not one of the 7 suspects. Are there any free thinkers whi feel the same ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey anybody think it was weird when lisbon is in the hospital and the nurse asks for "carmen lee or li"?? That was deff a message from red john but what does it mean?!?!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on