Who is Red John?

Theories of Stoopkid (372)

Let me ask you all this. WHAT IS LOGICAL ABOUT A PSYCHIC being hired by cops to catch a serial killer that killed his own family?!?!? Whats logical about CBI not being shut down the first 100 times people were killed inside their walls ? Its theatre people ! Not a science class! Heller admitted he didnt know who red john was till this season!!!! Thats a very illogical approach ehh?!?!?!?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #15573 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

For all you haters out there , when red john said he created the blake association ; that answered 95 percent of the questions . If you didn't like the episode thats totally fine . But dont say it was badly written and that no answers were given. Thats shit! Your acting like the mentalist isnt a semi cheesy show with cheesy dialogue ! You know its main demographic is old ladies too. Im 28 and i love it , but i am also honest about what it is and was. Jane didnt wanna give rj the satisfaction about explaining how he guessed the list. That was cool. When jane strangled him after making rj feel sorry for everything was wicked and cool. The gurgling was great. It wasnt partridge and you need to understand that. Why wasnt it bp? Becuase bp had an even lesser role on the show than maclister ! Seriously he had like 5 lines and jane rippwd him apart every-time. Partridge was cool cuz he sucked and was dumb and jane destroyed him verbally.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Dear brett partridge fans, he is so dead.
I suggest watching DEXTER. It ends bad too like most shows but hey at least its a forensics guy as a serial killer :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have a feeling macalister used timothy carter to kill james family because he was a real weirdo. RED JOHN NEVER EXISTED! DEXTER MORGAN IS NOT RED JOHN!!!
The sheriff was more of a mob leader than a serial killer . Bruno heller had no idea who rj was they rushed this season for us! The mentalist had so many red herrings ! The reason why this show was so great was that it made every character too suspicious! Van pelt rigsny even jane seemed like red john at some point . Thats what heller was good at. Using camera angles and facial expressions. All that crap with lorelie and kristina frye and styles was just crap to make u watch the show. They were in danger of being cancelled so they pulled herrings out their asses!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I thought the episode was awesome . I didn't like it the first time but now i understand it all. Everything was explained by the discovery of the Blake Association. Thats how red john was one step ahead. But it was NEVER red john that was a step of ahead, it was a whole organization. For all we know timothy carter the og red john could of killed Patrick's wife and daughter. Maybe the sherif did it himself. But what i learned from this episode was this...
Tom macalister was a power hungry control freak. A sadistic man who used women to do his bidding. Sort of like charles manson. He was obsessed with the game as patrick was for 6 seasons . Jane gave up this game because it played right into what red john wanted . Jane didnt care for an explanation about the tricks and magic this serial killer created. Jane realized hes just an obsessed guy who doesnt have many friends. "He craves" the affection and attention . Jane gave him none . He wasn't a serial killer he was a mob boss more so in that he was drunk with power and got offended at janes remarks . He wasn't visualize religious or really had any doctrine except power and control . He was a sheriff for crying out loud!
I loved that jane strangled him. It was wicked and twisted . Also jane made macalisters last thoughts be "regretting killing janes family" and "being afraid to die" . No smiley faces here. Gurgle gurgle lights out .
In conclusion, red john never existed . The image macalister created was a facade. A red herring . A game . He was the leader of a mob called the blake association. He was a sick mentally ill prick too but he WAS NOT DEXTER MORGAN!!!
The writing was great . The birds are dinosaurs line went way over peoples heads. Think about our government and how they act . Wink wink right back at u mr heller ;)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After dwelling on the leaked episode i have discovered that it all seemed like a dream from patrick. Probrally while hes in the hospital. The dialogue from the team members seems like its what Patrick thinks they would say. Especially when the guy says to lisbon about them two dating when he says " thats a shame " lol just a theory that i hope is true . But it did have a dream weird feel to it

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

People hate me on this site cuz i think outside the box . This is my last van pelt is suspicious post. Cant wait for tonight !!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on