Who is Red John

Random musings...

What's the point in not chasing Cordero when he failed to kill Smith?

Did you notice that the USB lighter was already in the box (stucked in the hay) when Bertram opened it?

What kind of questions the spokeswoman would have been able to answer to on RJ matter?

The encrypted document has mostly of the "names" repeating themselves (the first by 8 and side to side). Looks like a bad prop.

What sense does make RJ taunt "... or until I catch you"? He could catch (and kill) PJ whenever he would. Especially the sheriff on the roof...

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Random musings... How comes that the corrupt TT cop has a "wrong" tattoo on his shoulder? It is clearly seen, that the dots are getting smaller towards the outside, not the inside...

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

OK, this is not a theory, just a market research.
Who would be willing to pay 10bucks to have Ep8 now, ready to download?

GREEN = I would pay
RED = I wouldn't pay

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

The ruin of the show is upon us. Everything is getting rushed up, absurd things happen. See for ex:

he is in an alley
nearby? come on...that’s really luck...

Mister Thomas?
come on... you never watch TV?

Hm... that guy looks like you... come on...
And what about someone whistling in the corridor, or Cho not checking if the body is Partridge's, or "they are shutting us down, [Scully]" ... ?

Nothing original going on. BH even said "it won't be a sort of Ten Little Indians type of of set up". Really? because it just sounds like that... incuding the "presumed dead", the judge in A.Christies' masterpiece, the sheriff here? [they didn't check for bodies, and whose foot that was it?]. And the "secret organization, with maybe thousands of members"... oh my... when BH invented it?

Sorry to say that, but I don't think they we'll come up with a good explanation for everything. And true fans, who watched and watched episodes down to a single frame, will demolish this botched finale of the RJ epic.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Hi, just watched 6/6. I fear the show ruin is coming... Some very absurd things going on.
Let's forget the cramming of the first episodes with clues/misleads... everybody shows to have some phobia and a liking for whistling. We also discover that Bret Stiles likes to paint faces on faces with blood... Not speaking about 2 (two) characters just a couple of words from death... How does TygerTyger is supposed to help me find out who's muredered you???? Say a name instead...

And how does that sound: "Meet me tomorrow night in my secluded, abandoned family residence - presumably alone - some 650 km from here, will you?" ???
And how a CBI director look completely helpless for hours (approx. from well before sunset till pitch black) on the coast road between SF and LA? She still had her badge and weapon, did she?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Sorry to disappoint many. The main argument against Kirkland being RJ - the fact that at mid season 5 Lorelei couldn't possibly know about him shaking hands with PJ - is void.

If PJ has included him in the list, on the handshake basis, he IS right. Or do you believe that PJ can't reason about season 5 as the fans do???

Of course, my statement is fit, if the writers of the show do follow the storyline, remember the events as the fan do. Which is not necesarily true, as - everybody knows - there are business rules, money interests which result in pressure, strict timetables and so on.

I hope there will be no cliche', illogical explanation, absurd twists. Would be a shame to ruin a successul, entertaining show.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of Stepas (27)