Who is Red John

McAllister was just another Timothy Carter. Stiles and Haffner are still alive. either Stiles is Red John and Haffner is his right hand or Haffner is Red John and Stiles is his mentor does anyone really believe McAllister survived the blast and Stiles and Haffner (who are way more interesting characters) just died without a second mention no fuckin way the big twist will be Stiles and Haffner are still alive it's also possible in the world of the Mentalist that Partridge or a Kirkland Twin are still in the race for whoisredjohn? just sayin it's possible what's not possible is Bruno Heller getting all pissed at CBS and deciding to sabotage the entire show and then moving on to his new tv show. . . . a show set in Gotham but without Batman....ya can't wait since the season isn't over I have to operate under the assumption that McAllister isn't Red John(just like Carter) and that this is a season long con by Heller &Co. to give us the rightfull RJ end story that everbody wants the show is Red John without him there is no show and when they do reveal the real RJ we will see him kill and we the audience will be shown all the answers in flashbacks key moments in the RJ story like actually seeing the death of Jane's family with Stiles or Haffner doing the killing or a scene that shows what he did to Christine Frye show me in flashback Red John painting a smiley face and you can't just tell us who Red John is you have to show us who RJ is you just can't have some retard sheriff from one random episode just show up do a bad impression of the voice and claim to be a real psychic Jane has always been one step ahead of the audience

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

There's no way Stiles and Haffner just die off screen and are never mentioned agian. They have to show what happened at Jane's house when the camera cuts away before the explosion that's where the Jane/Mentalist twist is McAllister is not Red John just another Timothy Carter and Timothy Carter was a more convincing Red John than McAllister there has to be more proof than a one time character just showing up and saying they are RJ this New Beginning is just a huge misdirection what's the logic? it's not like RJ dominated the show one or two RJ episodes and the finale how is the RJ story ruining the show without the RJ storyline The Mentalist is just another murder procedural jane's life after RJ's death is a DVD bonus featurette or a bunch of mini webisodes not the last season and a half (if there is a season 7) untill the end of the season I still believe Red John is still alive the list and the explosion is just RJ playing with Jane why let him live after the explosion if you are just gonna kill him the next day RJ is just toying with Jane

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

I think Heller has something awesome planned for the last third of the season. I think something more happened in Jane's house when the camera cut away. The fact that they don't show what happened is a huge clue that we haven't seen the whole story yet. There is some kind of Mentalist twist yet to be played. because nothing since the explosion has made sense or even felt like The Mentalist the only one in the show that has even come close to Red John is Patrick Jane Patrick Jane has been there since the first episode(Jane going to sleep under the RJ smiley face) Jane has had a fucked up childhood(we haven't even seen all the trauma) Jane has had a mental breakdown(multiple personality??) Jane has a sleeping disorder RJ is supposed to be Jane's equal but evil Jane is playing a game with himself He's already killed two "Red Johns" not only has he killed two men in cold blood he has gotten away with it Jane killed his family and to deal with it he has created a group of serial killers all of them playing Red John giving himself something to do Killing that's how Red John knew his list that's why RJ is always one step ahead of Jane.. impossible to catch

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

If McAllister can fake his death than so can Partridge,Stiles or Haffner. The timing of the Red John death this early in the season doesn't make any sense I know that we haven't seen the last of Red John Abbott, Fisher, and Whyle could all be Red John accomplices

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

I think Red John is a cult of serial killers and all of the members are Red John. Timothy Carter was a Red John and McAllister was also a Red John. That's why when Carter and McAllister both say they were Red John Jane(the human lie detector) believes them because they both believed they were each Red John I think that maybe McAllister was the Red John who killed Jane's family but he was ordered to do it by the real Red John that's why he blinked that he was sorry for killing his family

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Red John is a group of serial killers headed by Patrick Jane. They are all playing the role of Red John all of them are made to play a "game" with Jane. Jane the leader of Red John ends this sick game he's playing with himself by killing each "Red John" and getting away with it that's why Timothy Carter was so surprised when Jane shot him and McAllister pissed himself and begged for his life and after Carter is killed Jane smiles and sits back down and after Jane chokes McAllister to death with his bare hands he goes on a two year vacation in paradise everything comes in threes and McAllister was the second RJ fake reveal / death and the third and final one will somehow expose Jane as the mastermind of "Red John" I called it when I first heard Red John's voice that it was Simon Baker's voice just whispered the RJ voice McAllister did was not Baker's voice every time we hear Red John's voice it's Jane's talking to himself playing a game with himself Luthor Wainwright called Jane a sociopath and he was kidnapped and set up to be killed why Wainwright ? cause he insulted Jane what about Bosco? he stole the RJ case from Jane and was mean to him and shut him out why would RJ go from killing Jane's family to teach him a lesson to helping Jane out by killing Bosco's team so Jane can have the case back? then he wants Jane to join him and promises him a new better life... a new beginning sends a hot chick to fuck him and then she helps him out... . . . Jane's behind everything Red John has to be Jane's equal . . .the symmetry the only person in the show's history who has shown Jane's level of skill and power is Patrick Jane the only person who could lure out and hypnotize Kristina Frye He has a sleeping disorder he had a mental breakdown how creepy would it be to see Jane painting the RJ smiley face with his wife's blood in a flashback? JANE IS RED JOHN The Rigsby's are going to die the season is in three parts the first is Red John: The Final Chapter the second is A New Beginning and the third will be The Return of Red John

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

I believed McAllister when he said he wasn't Red John. I didn't buy his Red John reveal. Timothy Carter was a more convincing RJ than McAllister. The show has to convince the audience that the character is RJ and McAllister didn't convince me at all. you can't just have some character appear out of nowhere and just say they are Red John they have to prove it I have not heard one person say they were happy or satisfied about the RJ reveal the show hasn't even done a good job of making a new begining or given us a storyline that replaces the RJ story If Timothy Carter wasn't RJ and did such a good job of playing RJ than I believe McAllister was doing the same if Red John could hypnotize Christene Frye into a catatonic state than he could hypnotize Carter and McAllister to believe they are Red John Jane killed them both caues he believed they were RJ he believed them because they were hypnotized to believe they were RJ how does Bertram not know who RJ is but knows about the "silly voice" ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of RED_LUTZ (50)