Who is Red John?

Theories of RED_LUTZ (50)

LOL I might just be in denial but there's no way the Red John story is over.  The Mentalist up until the 7th episode of the 6th season has been some of the smartest and most entertaining television on network T.V. . . . but nothing since Jane's house exploding has made any sense!!!   Before the explosion why cut away?  why not show what happened in the house with the gunshot?   the Bertram is Red John fake out again ???  episode 8 was such a farce    the sheer stupidity of this episode compared to any other episode in the series is what makes me believe Jane has been in a coma since the explosion    the way Bertram dies ??? Heyyy?  PATRICK JANE HIDING A PIGEON IN HIS SUIT JACKET POCKET......THROWING IT AT RED JOHN(WHO HAS A GUN)........go back and watch that scene where McAllister is trying to swat away that pigeon and tell me this isn't an explosion fueled coma nightmare........THEN MCALLISTER GETS SHOT BY A GUN JANE STASHED............they search Jane but not the church?.......JANE TURNS INTO AN ASSASSIN AND KILLS CORDERO .......picked him off pretty good for someone who doesn't like guns......BUT THE MENTALIST HIMSELF PATRICK JANE CAN'T TELL THE CRAZY BITCH SLOWLY COMING UP THE AISLE IS A RJ FOLLOWER ?? .............that was Red John"s backup plan? a middle aged crazy lady with a box cutter....ya , in case the police detective with the silencer gets killed McAllister's back up plan is this lady and he acts like he's not Red John A HELPLESS AND SHOT MCALLISTER GETS UP AND HAS A FOOT RACE WITH JANE .....CALLS 911 !!!!!  BLINKS SORRY!!! JANE CHOKES HIM TO DEATH WITH HIS BARE HANDS!!!     THEN THE SHOW TIME WARPS TWO YEARS......                                                                                                                   I always hoped Red John was someone not on the list from Jane's carnie past with strong ties to Visulize.....or Red John was a group of serial killers ....or Jane was Red John,,,,,whatever.......up until season 6 I was sure it was Partridge but when he was killed I thought either it's a fake death or he wasn't RJ and really was dead    and if he's dead who could it be?   i then thought Kirkland or Stiles would make the best Red John  --the actors who would give the best performance and that is what would make them too obvious   so I thought it would logically be Haffner(Red Barn episode)  they already did the Bertrum is Red John fake out in Peaches n Cream  and who gives a flyin fuck bout Reede and Mcallister cause they were only in one episode each and never mentioned again till the List of 7            THIS IS ALL TIMOTHY CARTER AGAIN JUST TAKEN TO A HIGHER LEVEL         if it wasn't for the Heller and Baker interviews before episode 8 and this site and I watched it without spoilers I would have never believed McAllister was RJ     season 6 should end with the reveal of the real Red John and the end of the 7th and final season should end with the death of Red John                there's still plenty of time left in the season for Red John to pop up and when he does the hardcore fans who had given up are back on board and the new fans will want to go back and watch every ep from the series          the Mentalist has enough episodes to make it into syndication doing all this now doesn't make sense      i have faith Heller has some master plan          i won't judge or condemn until the end of the season because..

......THE SEASON 6 FINALE CLIFFHANGER WILL BE RED JOHN IS STILL ALIVE AND EVERBODY WILL GO FUCKIN NUTS        AGREE?                                                                                                                                      

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

My only problem on this site is people coming on this site which is called Who Is Red John? And making fun of people posting theory's about who they think Red John is The way the show has been from the beginning it very well could be Rigsby? It could be anyone and if it is Rigsby it would be way more exciting than if it was a bumpkin sherif who only appeared once way back in the first season They could have Rigsby come out all suave and dapper with and English accent playing it real cold explaining how he pulled everything off If you like bland network tv shows nonody gives a fuck about staring Simon Baker go by The Guardian season 1 on DVD and go fuck yourself and stay off this site if people posting theory's about who red John is upsets you And if saying that makes me mean baker than I'm fine with that cause u sound like an oversensitive bitch.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anyone who is just here to hate n pick on people like Stoppkid are trolls and should be banned I may not agree with everything he says but at least he is posting theories that are entertaining and he's one of the ones keeping the site alive the site is called WHOISREDJOHN? if you think rj is McAllister than why r u on this site and if you love this new beginnings storyline than you are a fuckin moron RED JOHN is still alive. I don't care what Heller or Baker say in interviews or what the episode titles are. Nothing that has happened has convinced me McAllister is Red John. Nothing about this is the Mentalist . Unless Heller got into a big blowout with CBS and this is just a big fuck you Red John is still alive But even that doesn't make any sense cause why punish the loyal fans. The best thing about this coma dream is Cho finally showing some personality I apologize for my perfect English I'm from North America

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The more I think about it the better I feel bout everything . . . .cause Red John isn't dead !           It's sad to see this site go to shit    has everyone given up?     does everyone actually think they would end the epic Red John storyline like this ?  this early in the season ?  no fuckin way  I don't care what Heller says        there's no way Timothy Carter plays a more convincing Red John than Red John         there's no way that the fat bald white samurai from this season dies with more dignity than Red John            even though it would be a cop out I would even accept that this is all a post explosion coma dream      so don't tell me that Red John is dead   and get over it     you get over it fuck face if you believe all this at face value you are the delusional one and if you are happy with the Red John reveal and this new beginning that you aren't a real Mentalist die hard    The Mentalist is Red John and Red John is the Mentalist             there is no show without Red John              THE SEASON FINALE WILL BE THE REVEAL THAT RED JOHN IS STILL ALIVE   AGREE?                  I won't judge episode 8 and get all upset untill the season is finished       from what i can tell no one outside the fan sites gives a fuck about this New Beginning and all the fans are upset about the Red John reveal    I haven't heard one person say episode 8 was great and they are happy and satisfied    Heller can still save the season and the show      SEASON 6 FINALE WE WILL SEE RED JOHN IS STILL ALIVE  AGREE? 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Red John is Haffner  or Partridge      either Partridge is Red John and pulled McAllister out of Jane's house after the concussion blast and Stiles and Haffner really are dead  or Haffner is Red John and had either Partridge or Michael Kirkland pull himself and Stiles out and McAllister is only saved so he can act as Red John and be the escape goat     everyone thinks Red John is dead   Stiles goes on a little vacation with his protege Red John(Haffner)   when Stiles finally dies from his illness Haffner goes off the rails and goes after Jane and everyone he loves                          RED JOHN IS HAFFNER OR PARTRIDGE  AGREE?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

LOL   How the hell could you buy into this coded list bullshit?   Red John isn't dead !!!  This is all a gift from Red John  -Jane's New Beginning-     Every season has had a cliffhanger finale- the finale is always the best episode cause it was all Red John and it left you blown away and wanting more.  What's gonna be the season 6 finale? what's gonna be that amazing episode where the stakes are high enough and you are wide eyed in suspense?  It has to be the Red John reveal . . .it has to be!!!    Hopefully they got enough new fans to boost ratings with this new beginning stunt that by the end of this season we find out somehow that Red John is still alive and this is all just another Timothy Carter play by Red John just toying with Jane  You thought I was dead?   WRONG!!!  did you enjoy your bullshit two year vacation? well I'm bored game back on!                how bout Red John slaughters the Rigsby Family   You want a new beginning? Seventh and final season is THE REAL RED JOHN goes on a killing spree the series finale is the death of Red John a series finale that answers all the questions and gives the fans the satisfying end that this brilliant show deserves      NOTHING ABOUT S06E08-Red John FEELS RIGHT OR EVEN MAKES SENSE !!!!  the whole series is Red John      they have left it so wide open for him to come back and still be alive   besides the fact McAllister just appeared out of nowhere and didn't really convince me he is Red John and the way he died? McAllister didn't go out like Red John he went out like someone who was made to play Red John the same way Timothy Carter was.   THERE'S NO WAY TIMOTHY CARTER COULD PLAY A MORE CONVINCING RED JOHN THAN RED JOHN             I think Jane is once again one step ahead of Red John playing the long con      he knew McAllister wasn't Red John that's why he didn't care to hear McAllister's explanation    the two year vacation is just like his fake breakdown in season 4             RED JOHN IS STILL ALIVE      AGREE?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The dumb dumbs who think McAllister is Red John are the same fucks who thought Timothy Carter was Red John.  If you are taking everything at face value then you haven't been watching the Mentalist.  Stoopkid knows what I'm sayin  right?       We haven't seen the last of Red John....mark my words

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on