Who is Red John?

Theories of PaulK (14)

Anyone who thinks "Oh they will renew the show, they will definetly explain all this shit this time" is - sorry - fuckin ridiculous. I got over the show after mccalister episode and I couldn't be happier - I just feel sorry for those more "optimistic". Don't hate me. Cheers.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi!

few months back, after the disaster rj episode I made a promise to myself I wont turn mentalist on - ever. I didn't brake the promise, but was still reading whoisredjohn, because it was always fun. BUT now - seeing only stoopkid being the lone ranger of this site, this site just don't make sense - because:

rj is mccalister
heller is a fuckin fraud

I will reenter this site after season finale is aired and see if there is one person will be satisfied with the show ending.

Cheers.

Paul


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Stoopkid, I dont get why you try so much to keep the discussion on the RJ on the surface so freakin bad? Everybody made their comment and good, but you.., i dont know it just seems something wrong with your input on this site. Not hating, just sayin.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi Everyone,

just wanted to add personal comment to all the other ones about what Mentalist turned into.

please, for heaven sakes, stop saying that it's gonna be awesome from
this and this episode in the future, it won't, beacause Heller, producers, actors
don't give a flying fuck about this anymore, why should you.

PS. I turned the episode on today, saw lame dialogue between fisher/Jane, stupid Lisbon faces (I like her alot, but now....), really low class acting and writing, Simon Bakers poor attempts to act like good old Jane, and finally this blond chick - criminal mastermind. And above it all - 80% of comments on facebook page says "Yay, no red john, new Patrick is awesome... ". I said few weeks back I won't watch this anymore, thought maybe I was little hasty in this decision, but no...

good thing there is Sherlock, one show we can actually rely on.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

One more thought:

Maybe Bruno Haha Heller, did the shitty "Sherrif is RJ" episode, to loosen the hype on RJ we all have been making for these years.

Besides, it is possible that Sherrif isn't real RJ, and was being pussy because he was "forced" to be fake RJ, and just didn't predict that Jane will beat him, just like with rock, paper, scisscors game. He couldn't have told Patrick that he is not RJ, because even if Patrick would spare him, real RJ would gutted him anyway.

Conclusion: Bruno "left" the opportunity that someone else (probably Partridge) is RJ, but for now, to bring the tension down he did another red herring.

It doesn't change the fact that its weak to copy "The Profiler".

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi all!

OK. The last scene.
After Jane disappears from camera, we can see a man (who some people think its Partridge) and a girl on a fun slide.

Now, the slide is DINOSAUR shaped.
Earlier, Jane was talking to lisbon that Birds are like MINI-DINOSAURS... so there is metaphor that the man beside the slide is a man who loves birds (pigeons), just like...

so I think to things:
At this slide it was red john.
He has a daughter.

Cheers!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Wow, Heller is a money grabbin fraud, didn't see that coming. If he had chosen whatever any other character for RJ, no one probably would care about 'the Profiler' resemblance. But he decided to fuck everybody with this crap. I dont give a rat ass if in my blue heaven Patrick gets a phonecall from cho that lisbon been raped and gutted and there is a smiley on her forhead.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on