Who is Red John?

Theories of MissStiles (23)

I've been thinking about the smiley face on the wall. 

I'm sorry but some of the suspects are such miserable, 'never smiling' people, that it would be weird if they used that as a signature. I've never even seen Bertram smile so there's absolutely no way he would be painting smiley faces, is there? Same with the sheriff really, I don't think he is that funny.

The two funniest suspects for me are Partridge and Stiles. I could especially imagine Partridge painting the smiley faces, he is a weirdo..

I know it probably will be the sheriff, but I've gone back to Partridge now.

It's the last few days without knowing so I want to support the one I want it to be, not the one I think it will be..:)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I've been thinking about the smiley face on the wall. 

I'm sorry but some of the suspects are such miserable, 'never smiling' people, that it would be weird if they used that as a signature. I've never even seen Bertram smile so there's absolutely no way he would be painting smiley faces, is there? Same with the sheriff really, I don't think he is that funny.

The two funniest suspects for me are Partridge and Stiles. I could especially imagine Partridge painting the smiley faces, he is a weirdo..

I know it probably will be the sheriff, but I've gone back to Partridge now.

It's the last few days without knowing so I want to support the one I want it to be, not the one I think it will be..:)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #12831 • By MissStiles
Show this theory

To be honest I was perfectly happy for the sheriff to be RJ until I saw the promo. Why did they have to ruin it for us? We are not supposed to know he is alive! If he just popped up in the next episode without us knowing, I would have been happy with it.

Now I don't want McAllister to be RJ, I would be much happier if it's Stiles or Haffner, at least we didn't see them in the promo. Ridiculous.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OMG, this website was down the whole day!!!! I was desperate to read other's opinions and I couldn't! :P

It looks like it's the sheriff, but it's very suspicious that they let us see him in the promo...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #11574 • By MissStiles
Show this theory

We've talked about the suspects so much in the last few weeks, that I will probably be not shocked at all by the reveal..At this point the only person who would surprise me is Stiles, because I'm sure it's not him. Lol.

We always say he knows RJ but he is not RJ, so he is the only one where I would say: "wow! I didn't see this coming! It was him this whole time?"

I still don't think it's him but I won't be shocked by anyone else unless there is a huge twist that leaves us all speechless.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Brand new interview about episode 7!

"there will be an answer to the fate of Brett Partridge".!!! (finally)

http://tvline.com/2013/11/15/the-mentalist-season-6-preview-final-three-red-john-suspects/

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Are you guys like me and you've been thinking about The Mentalist 'last chapter' for weeks??
I never ever thought I would care about any show this much in my life! I'm fanatical about the whole Red John storyline coming to an end! 

I've come full circle with the suspects, I started with Partridge, then dead Partridge, then Haffner, sheriff, later for a short time even Stiles, Bertram, Kirkland..Now I'm back with Haffner and the sheriff because I just don't know anymore..

The only two people I never ever thought of are Smith and Jane himself. I refuse to believe it's either of them..

Who is it going to be??? I'm going crazy!! Every suspect has something for them and against them, Bruno Heller has done a good job because we can't stop speculating! I don't think this has ever happened with any shows to such detail..It's nice to be part of The Mentalist community with you guys!:P




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on